[feature-request] move (conan) community maintained to official opencv maintained conan package recipe

Christian_Gunther · September 27, 2022, 9:15am

ok i moved the discussion to the github tracker:

revisit official Conan package for OpenCV

opened 09:14AM - 27 Sep 22 UTC

TLDR: i am aware of https://github.com/opencv/opencv/issues/10020, but i think r…evisiting current situation would be beneficial, since the heavy lifting is already done by the community to enable opencv builds with conan managed transitive dependencies even for the majority of cross-compilation setups. So it is at the moment potentially only a question of maintenance instead of making it work at all. ### Motivation: A lot of companies are integrating external library dependency management into their build (CI) tool chains. It is necessary to keep track of used compiler versions, propagation of necessary compiler flags, as well as the build configuration of the external library itself. All this can be achieved by conan io, which integrates nicely in the most used build management environments (like cmake, VS-Studio, etc.) and handles correctly multiple platforms like x86_64, M1 Mac, Android, iOS, etc. In my eyes conan acts already like a de-facto standard here, especially in the cross-compilation world. ### Current Situation: The heavy lifting is already done by the conan community and the opencv package is available on conan io for long-time. OpenCV is one of the interesting use-cases for cross-compilation and dependency management, especially for conan itself. So the community invested already a lot of effort to handle OpenCV transitive dependencies accordingly for the different platforms. The already existing OpenCV conan package is used for a clean implementation of a complex dependency showing all the necessary features of conan. Some resources about the conan opencv efforts: - outdated efforts for first heavy lifting: https://blog.conan.io/2019/02/11/OpenCV-conan-packages.html - current reciepe of OpenCV 4.5.5: https://github.com/conan-io/conan-center-index/blob/master/recipes/opencv/4.x/conanfile.py I personally can ensure that it is possible to run the OpenCV conan builds for an cross-platform native backend on desktop and apps like building: linux ci x86_64 → linux x86_64 linux ci x86_64 → linux arm aarch64 linux ci x86_64 → android ndk x86, x86_64, armv7, armv8 apple xcode x86_64 → ios x86, x86_64, armv7, armv8 Where i am really thankful that current tooling is able to handle that well. ### Problems at the moment In my eyes it is sad that new updates of OpenCV are taking a lot of time and effort to pin-point transitive dependency changes of OpenCV out after its release. Especially sad is, that the necessary dependency management should be known during development and just updating the conan recipes from OpenCV side itself should involve a lot less effort than doing it externally. ### Key benefits of moving to an OpenCV maintained conan package: reduced maintenance overhead, since transitive dependency changes would be handled directly when they occur during development instead of post release packaging the latency between opencv releases and the availability in conan can be reduced a lot the dependency management inside OpenCV might benefit potentially as well organizing it’s own dependencies that way **side-note:** Other large-scale open-source developments with tons of third-party dependencies are migrating also to self-maintained conan packages like Qt: https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/QTBUG-68854

Topic		Replies	Views
GUI not showing/hangs on imshow with Wayland backend (Ubuntu 22.04) C++ build	1	1040	April 14, 2024
Libopencv_world package undefined reference to xxx C++ build	9	2861	March 4, 2022
Compilation issues with gnu cc 11.2.0 (not C++) build , historical	1	297	April 3, 2022
Crosscompiling issues going from Ubuntu terminal to RPI4 raspberrypi , linux , build	4	830	June 29, 2023
What build do the official Opencv builds use? build , rust	4	896	August 30, 2021

[feature-request] move (conan) community maintained to official opencv maintained conan package recipe

Related topics